Please score these Morrissey/Nevin tracks

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 29227
  • Start date Start date
It's not insane at all robot.
'Tony...' is a thing of beauty!
The lovely understated guitar parts, the beautiful quivering cello, the bouncy bassline, the wistful lyrics, the rhyming of 'corner' with 'warn yer'.
It's genius pop and (as I mentioned before) M Nevin has declared it his favourite co-write.
Thanks for the back up! Didn't know that about Nevin. I think the intertwining guitars on the outro are up there with the end of Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others (which might be my favorite piece of Marr playing).
 
  1. (I'm) The End Of The Family Line 10
  2. Asian Rut 10
  3. Born To Hang** 8
  4. Driving Your Girlfriend Home 10
  5. I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday 10
  6. I've Changed My Plea To Guilty 9
  7. King Leer 10
  8. My Love Life 10
  9. Our Frank 10
  10. Pregnant For The Last Time 7
  11. Sing Your Life 10
  12. The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye 10
  13. The Loop 10
  14. There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends 9
  15. Tony The Pony 9
  16. You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side 10
 
(I'm) The End Of The Family Line 8.5
Asian Rut 7.5
Born To Hang 7.5
Driving Your Girlfriend Home 7
I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday 8
I've Changed My Plea To Guilty 8.5
King Leer 8
My Love Life 9.5
Our Frank 9
Pregnant For The Last Time 6.5
Sing Your Life 10
The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye 6
The Loop 8.5
There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends 7.5
Tony The Pony 7.5
You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side 8
 
  1. (I'm) The End Of The Family Line 7/10
  2. Asian Rut 2/10
  3. Born To Hang
  4. Driving Your Girlfriend Home 7/10
  5. I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday 10/10
  6. I've Changed My Plea To Guilty 6/10
  7. King Leer 6/10
  8. My Love Life 5/10
  9. Our Frank 6/10
  10. Pregnant For The Last Time 7/10
  11. Sing Your Life 7/10
  12. The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye 3/10
  13. The Loop 8/10
  14. There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends 8/10
  15. Tony The Pony 6/10
  16. You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side 7/10
 
New leader this morning, by a mere 0.02...had to go to 2 decimal places to split the top two (otherwise we'd have a joint leader).
Only 0.22 total difference between 1st & 3rd place...4th place trailing 3rd by 0.26...it's tight.
Bottom 3 all in the mid-hi 5's...:eek:

Please note, am closing this thread tomorrow 12:00 UK time, so please get your votes in.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  1. (I'm) The End Of The Family Line 8
  2. Asian Rut 8
  3. Born To Hang** 9
  4. Driving Your Girlfriend Home 9
  5. I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday 10
  6. I've Changed My Plea To Guilty 10
  7. King Leer 8
  8. My Love Life 8
  9. Our Frank 10
  10. Pregnant For The Last Time 10
  11. Sing Your Life 10
  12. The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye 9
  13. The Loop 10
  14. There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends 10
  15. Tony The Pony 7
  16. You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side 9
 
(I'm) The End Of The Family Line - 7
Asian Rut - 6
Born to Hang - 6.5
Driving Your Girlfriend Home - 6.5
I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday - 9
I've Changed My Plea To Guilty - 9
King Leer - 7
My Love Life - 7
Our Frank - 7.5
Pregnant For The Last Time - 7.5
Sing Your Life - 8
The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye - 6.5
The Loop - 7
There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends - 7
Tony The Pony - 6.5
You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side - 8
 
Last edited:
A shift again this morning, with just 1 single point separating the top 2, with 3rd place trailing by some 9 points, so it's all to play for again.
Voting will close in 2.5 2 1.5 1 hour 30 20 10 5 mins.
Best voter turnout thus far: 40, so thanks to those who have taken part (y).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  1. Asian Rut. 6
  2. Born To Hang**. 6 (can’t really remember)
  3. Driving Your Girlfriend Home. 8
  4. I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday. 9
  5. I've Changed My Plea To Guilty. 10
  6. King Leer. 6
  7. My Love Life. 7
  8. Our Frank. 6
  9. Pregnant For The Last Time. 5
  10. Sing Your Life. 8
  11. The Harsh Truth Of The Camera Eye. 7
  12. The Loop. 9
  13. There's A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends. 8
  14. Tony The Pony. 7
  15. You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side. 8
Not such a songwriter after all. It is just that some of his best work appeared as b-sides (the loop, I changed my plea) and on YA, where his songs sounded much stronger. His efforts on KU by contrast didn’t come across so well.
 
5th place: Our Frank - 7.96 (318.5 points)

4th place: Sing Your Life - 8.28 (331 points)

3rd place: You're Gonna Need Someone On Your Side - 8.49 (339.5 points)

2nd place: I Know It's Gonna Happen Someday - 8.76 (350.5 points)

1st place & The Winner with 8.78 (351 points) is:




 
To conclude, here's the complete, & final, scorings:

Participants = 40 validated people, comprising:
34 members
6 'anons'

Thanks to all who took part (y)

For convenience, have put all the graphical data below.

Here's a graph showing total average scores received/track:

final scores nevin.JPG

Here's a graph showing total points received/track:

final points nevin.JPG

...and finally, of course, the Pareto chart:

pareto nevin.JPG
 
Back
Top Bottom