Na, you are too harsh. This guy whipped this up on his iMac with a MIDI keyboard and a plug-in of some type. Plays the notes perfectly, nice drum track, and some nice swell effects, in perfect time. This is what is so beautiful about a modern MIDI based DAW sitting on your desktop. I like it.
I purchased the Smiths the day it came out and and saw them during their Meat is Murder and Queen is Dead tours. The Smiths are like no other! Also, the MOZ was brilliant up until Vauxhall saw him a few years back at the Palladium during his residency and he still has it in him. His current band is good live, but not very good in the studio their sound does not fit Morrissey's voice and too much distortion. But dear Smith fan's Unite and do yourself a huge favor by streaming the new Shins stream on iTunes. It is killer and up there with the best Smiths records!