As proclaimed in South Park, Disintegration is the greatest ever album of all time. Conclusive proof that both of you are woefully mistaken.
Not it isn't. It is the most overrated album of all time, and a weaker album than anything that preceded it in the band's production. It is to the Cure what Tonight is to David Bowie - the beginning of the pointless part of their career. In my personal opinion.
Consider the type of people that watch South Park.
I watch South Park, and consider it the most intelligent satire ever produced by a long-running series on American television. OK, not that that says much, but still....
At it's best, it is sublimely devastating, often because it doesn't shy away from vulgarity and profanity where that is in fact entirely appropriate (as in the brilliant Paris Hilton episode). Not unlike a certain Manchester-born singer, now that I think on it....