Eddie Vedder joins Johnny on stage to sing "There Is A Light..."

Eddie Vedder joined Johnny Marr at the Ohana festival 29th Sept to sing There Is A Light.....
Will try and put a video of it on here later.

---

Posted by Famous when dead:

 

[Nikita]

Not convinced at all by the vocals, but what strikes me is that JM is basically doing what he reproached to Mon, singing There is a light as an anthem.

 

[g23]

There is a yarl that never goes yarl.

Eddie's one of those guys that I didn't like in his prime. Overly earnest, overly serious, and the music seemed formulated in a lab for maximum angst. This was entertaining, but I don't know that I'll ever revisit it. Kind of a disposable oddity. But it got press without resorting to weird antics, didn't it?

 

[Nikita]

Also, I am wondering, has Marr ever performed a Smiths song that Morrissey did not before?

 

[Anonymous]

Also, I am wondering, has Marr ever performed a Smiths song that Morrissey did not before?

You Just Haven't Earned It Yet, Baby?

 

[Famous when dead]

You Just Haven't Earned It Yet, Baby?

Morrissey's played this about 10 times after The Smiths.
See the Swords live in Warsaw for a good recording.



I think Nowhere Fast is the least frequent. Marr has performed it once and Morrissey 4 times. To answer the question: no, I don't think he's played anything Moz hasn't done himself.
Regards,
FWD.

 

[Anonymouswithapologies]

We have really reached the end of the line, haven’t we?

What’s next? A duet with Paul Potts?

use your logic.... umm... justin...









justin t-shirt timbaland

 

[Anonymouswithapologies]

We have really reached the end of the line, haven’t we?

What’s next? A duet with Paul Potts?

use your logic.... umm... justin...









justin t-shirt timbaland

 

[9 x Fined]

Never in a million years would I ever click on this. Eddie Vedder. Bleh.

 

[ZOOM FROM GLOOM]

Ahh, if only.

The ONLY WAY it should ever be done.

Without Morrissey singing it... could only turn out a travesty.




But, E Vedder !? JFC what a awful voice, if we can even call it that.

 

[ZOOM FROM GLOOM]

There is a yarl that never goes yarl.

Eddie's one of those guys that I didn't like in his prime. Overly earnest, overly serious, and the music seemed formulated in a lab for maximum angst. This was entertaining, but I don't know that I'll ever revisit it. Kind of a disposable oddity. But it got press without resorting to weird antics, didn't it?

I would call this incident a ‘ weird antic ‘. And
a crying shame Marr is ruining the Smiths legacy in this way.

Yeah,What’s up with that f..king yarl ?!
I remember when I first heard EV’s yarl and
felt it really must be the end of pop music. But wasn’t that like a thing at the time? that spread? like when you hear people sing with a fake ass country twang or southern drawl in their voice? I don’t know, always bothers me.

 

[Vesper Nocturne]

I just clicked on it. omfg. So much bad-ness. I wish i could just give him some money to not ever do that again. B-A-D stuff happening WATCH OUT

 

[vegan cro spirit 55]

HORRIBLE SITUATION!!!!!!!!


DRAMAJ IS RUINING THE SMITHS LEGACY!!!

WITH HIS HORRENDOUS SINGING OF MOZ SONGS!!!!

 

[realitybites]

Last 1:30 was absolutely brilliant.

The Eddie spin!

 

[Zoinks]

This headline with Moz mention:

http://www.vanyaland.com/2018/10/01...-the-role-of-morrissey-at-a-johnny-marr-show/

 

[Famous when dead]

It appears Johnny returned the favour and came on stage to sing Hard Sun during Eddie's set on the 29th:



Not really my cup of tea, but I'm sure the ardent Marr fans will enjoy.
More my thing (from last week):


Regards,
FWD.

 

[g23]

I would call this incident a ‘ weird antic ‘. And
a crying shame Marr is ruining the Smiths legacy in this way.

Yeah,What’s up with that f..king yarl ?!
I remember when I first heard EV’s yarl and
felt it really must be the end of pop music. But wasn’t that like a thing at the time? that spread? like when you hear people sing with a fake ass country twang or southern drawl in their voice? I don’t know, always bothers me.

I wouldn't say this was that weird. People sing with other people all the time. It's just a case of a weird voice to apply to The Smiths. It's overly masculine and affected, and doesn't work with the music.

Elsewhere on the internet, a version of E-bow the Letter by REM with Thom Yorke was hyped earlier in the week and I felt the same way. His vocal was thin, often off key, and neurotic in that Thom Yorke kind of way. I missed Patti Smith's vocal. I felt the same hearing Eddie. Like a beautiful dessert, topped with onions.

 

[Paul Calf]

Bag of shite

 

[Anonymous]

get off the stage, loser

 

[Vesper Nocturne]

HORRIBLE SITUATION!!!!!!!!


DRAMAJ IS RUINING THE SMITHS LEGACY!!!

WITH HIS HORRENDOUS SINGING OF MOZ SONGS!!!!

I want to know what the difference is between vegan dot cro, you vegan cro spirit 55, and then that other vegan whatever 11.

Inquiring minds want to know!!

 

[ZOOM FROM GLOOM]

I wouldn't say this was that weird. People sing with other people all the time. It's just a case of a weird voice to apply to The Smiths. It's overly masculine and affected, and doesn't work with the music.

Elsewhere on the internet, a version of E-bow the Letter by REM with Thom Yorke was hyped earlier in the week and I felt the same way. His vocal was thin, often off key, and neurotic in that Thom Yorke kind of way. I missed Patti Smith's vocal. I felt the same hearing Eddie. Like a beautiful dessert, topped with onions.

Thin is a good way to describe York’s ... ‘voice’
Could never understand what people see in him, maybe the times just called for a new token weirdo that was safe, and he just fit the bill.