Absolutely scathing ROTT Review



After a nearly flawless career with the Smiths (with a lot of help from Johnny Marr) and one amazing solo album in 1988’s Viva Hate, Morrissey has become one of the least ambitious idols in all of rock. His newest album is at best a parody of old Morrissey. He has become boring. He has become stagnant. He has become irrelevant.

In a scene from the Noah Baumbach film The Squid and the Whale, young Walt Berkman tries to impress a girl by talking about Kafka’s Metamorphosis. It is obvious that he has never read the book, and as he rambles on he mentions that the book is Kafkaesque. The girl responds by saying something to the effect of “Well, yeah, Kafka wrote it.” But Walt made a keen observation, whether he meant to or not: almost all idols of popular culture eventually become bigger than their human likenesses. They can even come full circle, and become a copy of themselves.

So now comes Morrissey with his new album, Ringleader of the Tormentors. He is the indie-pop god of all gods. He is the Fitzgerald to Thurston Moore’s Joyce and Stephen Malkmus’s Hemingway. But unlike Moore and Malkmus, Morrissey has become an old, stale indie-pop idol. He hasn’t evolved at all in 18 years of solo work. He has become Morrissey-esque. Old Morrissey, with the Smiths and his early solo work, was true gloom. New Morrissey is just old gloom rehashed. He is trying hard to remember what it was like to be pissed off and unhappy, but it just isn’t working.

It’s not his fault at all that Morrissey circa-1986 can now sound boring as well. The pop scene has hashed and rehashed his sound so many times that his once-strange croon now sounds like the latest pop disaster. But what is Morrissey’s fault is that he hasn’t adapted. He goes on like no one has ever heard, let alone commandeered, his style or words.

In a recent television interview with Dave Fanning on the Ovation Network, Moz had the audacity to say that there are no decent pop vocalists or lyricists around. Even just off the top of my head, I can name several bands/artists who I think are vocally and lyrically superior to current Morrissey, and are doing more important work in the realm of pop music: Neutral Milk Hotel, Destroyer, Devendra Banhart, Of Montreal, Will Oldham, the Decemberists, and Bright Eyes. That’s just an eclectic few out of many.

After Morrissey’s claim about the state of pop music, Fanning was visibly taken aback. But still Morrissey pressed on, asking Fanning if any pop music had touched him recently. When Fanning mentioned a Nick Cave song that he thought really makes a stand lyrically and vocally, Morrissey dismissed it by saying that Fanning was prepared to like the song since he was already a Nick Cave fan.

This is a perfect example of the arrogant, delusional world that Morrissey lives in. He refuses to adapt to a changing musical landscape. While many purists applaud him for it, it is really his downfall. When Dylan went electric, a lot of people were pissed. But “Like a Rolling Stone” is one of the greatest pop singles of all time because Dylan grew and adapted and wrote the song for a changing society.

The first single from Ringleader of the Tormentors, “You Have Killed Me”, is the perfect example that he isn’t doing anything new. He prides himself on his amazing lyrical content, but the lyrics here are dull compared to anything he did with the Smiths. Sure, he is still aiming to be the king of gloom, but “As I live and breathe / You have killed me / You have killed me / Yes I walk around somehow / But you have killed me / You have killed me / Piazza Cavour, what’s my life for?” are some of the most banal lyrics imaginable. Compare them with something like the lyrics to “There Is a Light That Never Goes Out”:

And if a double-decker bus crashes in to us
To die by your side is such a heavenly way to die
And if a ten ton truck kills the both of us
To die by your side
Well the pleasure, the privilege is mine.

These lyrics are gloomy and at the same time literary and soulful. And if you want to get into solo Morrissey, “Everyday Is Like Sunday” is a blockbuster, lyrically.

Another song on Ringleader, “In the Future When All’s Well”, features some of the most typical rock guitar I’ve ever heard. This is the song that made me immediately wish Johnny Marr would get out of his rut and return to give Morrissey some help. The vocals on this track are shaky and unsure, as well. This is especially surprising; whether you love him or hate him, the one thing Morrissey never exhibited in his croon was uncertainty. Here the vocals are flat, not like the Morrissey of “There Is a Light that Never Goes Out”, where the vocals are so round and ambitious that they well up in your stomach.

Musically, Morrissey has been stagnant for the last five or six albums, but lyrically it seems like he’s actually regressed in some aspects. Long gone are the tales of dark humor and loveless nights. You can’t fake gloom, and it seems like Morrissey is desperately trying to do that. At the end of “You Have Killed Me”, he sings: “And there is no point saying this again”. Take your own advice, Moz.

Before his death, Morrissey will probably crank out a hundred more albums and none of them will be particularly bad. The only thing this proves is that Morrissey has attained such indie-god status that no one is willing to believe he can do any wrong. But each new album will most likely be a carbon copy of his former self. And with every copy the image gets a little more distorted.

There is SOME truth to this, but I don't think ROTT or the current Moz is all that bad.


Junior Member
I was laughing out loud as I read it. Banal lyrics? My emotional connection with his current material is as strong as ever. That's what counts, either you get the music or you don't. Morrissey is as relevant as ever in my experience. ROTT, I love it. As I write i am going over the You Have Killed Me lyrics in my head and thinking of the review. Doing so only affirms for me music is a subjective experience. Stating the obvious perhaps but people forget this.


Senior Member
I don't know why they bother getting someone who obviously hates Morrissey to do the review. What's the point?


I don't think the reviewer hates Morrissey at all -- in fact, I believe that he LOVES Moz, and perhaps believes (like many of us) that a truly great album still exists within him...if only he would make it.

I don't dislike ROTT, but I have to admit that I do agree with this reviewer on many of his points.


Senior Member
MrRoboto said:
I don't think the reviewer hates Morrissey at all -- in fact, I believe that he LOVES Moz, and perhaps believes (like many of us) that a truly great album still exists within him...if only he would make it.

I don't dislike ROTT, but I have to admit that I do agree with this reviewer on many of his points.

So he's not liked anything he's done since Viva Hate and he loves him? I'm sorry, if he liked him even a little bit he'd be able to find something of worth in that body of work. Even non fans do.


Senior Member
I don't suspect there will be many people here who can view this review with a critical eye, but the reality is there are many people, including long time fans, who agree with much of what the author has said.

I have been a Smiths/Moz fan for 20 years now, and I love the Man dearly. But I have to admit, in recent years - both on YATQ and ROTT - there have been some extremely "banal" lyrics. Overall I find ROTT a disappointment, musically and lyrically. I don't hate it, but it's not something that left me speechless. And that's what I expect from Moz. That's what he's delivered in the past, time and again.

I remember being so moved by the Smiths and much of Moz's earlier work. Listening to Viva Hate for the first time was a benchmark experience in my life. Hearing The Smiths was like being initiated into something bigger. And now the club I find myself in has become somewhat less interesting over the last few years.

I love Moz and will 'til the end. I'll continue to buy his albums and see him live. But I just wish he'd put out something that left me speechless again, sitting in my chair with my mouth open amazed at what I've just heard on my stereo.

I miss that Moz.

- unrulyboy -


Senior Member
I think what people don't take into account when they want Morrissey to surprise and amaze them is that the main element that surprised them in the first place was someone new coming along with a different point of view.

You now know Morrissey so he's not going to surprise you in the same way, unless you want him to be a Madonna or Bowie and adopt different personas.

Personally, Morrissey has never written songs that I can identify with more than the songs on ROTT.


New Member
Despite what he says, he doesn't do himself any favors by naming bands that only 3 people listen to as 'superior artists' and wishing for a reunion with Marr even though he himself admits that Marr isn't doing anything spectacular these days.


Senior Member
One can think whatever he wants, but there is one thing which is obvious and can't be seriously discussed is that Morrissey sings better and better over the years


...that's if I had one.
The impression I got from reading the review was of someone trying to swim against Moz's "indie-god status" in order to differentiate him/herself from the crowd. Someone who, by doing so, wants to call attention to their "authentic" indie or esoteric preferences.

Add to that the odd decision to identify Morrissey's psychological state and then slam it ("arrogant, delusional world that Morrissey lives in") and you have a piece of writing that is not authentic criticism. It is a vanity piece for the author.

I welcome intelligent criticism of art -- not hipster posturing.

Top Bottom