> The Bob Marley - Legend compilation is my favourite of all time, I think
> it has 14 songs but I can't be arsed checking right now. "A mid
> priced" 14 song compilation would be perfect. But for 15 quid I'd
> expect at least 18.
that's what i'm talking about, david. cd's are entirely too expensive for there to only be 14 songs on them -- unless they're proper albums. with compilations, i expect more bang for my buck (especially in the case of the smiths and morrissey where i already have every song anyway). i also expect a tracklist that flows nicely -- none of this shoddily cobbled together stuff -- although this isn't a problem i've had with smiths/moz compilations.
for my money, one of the best (non smiths or moz) compilations is "the best of blur" which i think isn't available in the UK. it has two discs, one with 18 songs (one of them not available on a proper album) and one with 10 live songs. it cost me about $18, which is about how much regular cd's cost here. "the complete stone roses" is also incredibly generous with 21 songs.