posted by davidt on Tuesday January 30 2007, @12:00PM
Quintin writes:
There's a mention of The Smiths and a poll "which group do you most want to reform?"

Pink Floyd are leading - but we could change all that.

Reunion fever sweeps rock world - BBC News
A string of bands have announced comebacks - but why do they do it, and who could be next?

Excerpt:

...The return of The Smiths, The Stone Roses or The Jam would cause a frenzy in the UK, Mr Sutherland adds.

Frosty relations

"That's the holy trinity right there if you could get those three bands to reform.

"But they're probably three of the most unlikely reformations out there because there does seem to be a genuine degree of antipathy between the members."

Their frontmen - Morrissey, Ian Brown and Paul Weller - have also enjoyed successful solo careers and so are less likely to need the windfall.

The chances of a reunion go up as the fortunes of the band's members go down and their egos and wallets long once more for the glory days.

But rock history proves that time is a great healer - and money can be a very useful medicine.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough:
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • Morrissey would never reunite with The Smiths again.

    I actually remember him saying when money was mentioned:

    "There isn't enough money in the world"
    Jack the Ripper1 <[email protected]> -- Tuesday January 30 2007, @12:23PM (#247316)
    (User #17841 Info | http://aboutmorrissey.blogspot.com/)
  • My dear pal Swallowneck would rather see the reformation of Candy Flip than a full-blown Smiths reunion.

    He often says "let sleeping dogs lie" when we visit the kennels at the weekends to give the neglected hounds a bit of exercise...
    MarkFromScatter -- Tuesday January 30 2007, @12:30PM (#247320)
    (User #16900 Info)
    If you don't like me, don't look at me...
  • Auspicious Wish -

    'At this very moment for the peoples and the nations of the earth,
    May not even the names famine, disease, war and suffering be heard;
    But rather may their moral conduct, merit, wealth and prosperity increase,
    And may supreme good fortune and wellbeing always arise for them.'
      - Kyabjé Dudjom Rinpoche

    Here is, I trust, a timely message that would extend to all warring parties of super pop-bands and even at exceptionally lenient moments, to the swallownecks of this world… Maybe…
    goinghome -- Tuesday January 30 2007, @02:42PM (#247360)
    (User #12673 Info)
  • It struck me to watch Morrissey in New York Doll. Here he is, talking about how great it was to see his favorite band in the entire universe reforming for the fans. He's obviously awestruck, and he talks about how wonderful it is that Arthur Kane and David Johansen were able to come together after so long and forget their differences, and just play for the joy of being together making music again.

    I thought, why won't he allow this for the Smiths? Put all the crap behind you and look how great it could be...even if it's just him and Johnny, what is it that's holdng them both back? Obviously they don't need the money, but why wouldn't they want to get together again for themselves, for the fans, and for the music? It could be great for them too.

    Killer Kane died a happy man because they finally put it behind them and played again. Maybe there's a lesson there?

    Let's all keep dreaming, and keep those fingers crossed, and maybe it will happen (after Andy and Mike die?)
    Grillo <[email protected]> -- Tuesday January 30 2007, @09:39PM (#247392)
    (User #6298 Info)
    • Re:NY Doll by Musley (Score:1) Wednesday January 31 2007, @04:10AM
    • Re:NY Doll by Anonymous (Score:0) Wednesday January 31 2007, @10:58AM
  • Part of the integrity of the three bands mentioned ,The Jam, The Smiths and the Stone Roses, apart from the quality of their back catalogues, is that they haven't watered it down by coming back.

    I dread to think what The Police will be like.
    Will Sting bring his jazz noodlings to the fore?
    Will Andy Summers live long enough?
    Anonymous -- Wednesday January 31 2007, @05:49AM (#247409)
    • Re:reunions by Some Old Queen (Score:1) Wednesday January 31 2007, @10:56AM
      • Re:reunions by Anonymous (Score:0) Wednesday January 31 2007, @11:25AM
  • But I Would love a Pink Floyd reunion more.
    bmaull -- Wednesday January 31 2007, @11:05AM (#247422)
    (User #13999 Info)


[ home | terms of service ]