If Johnny Marr, Andy Rourke & Mike Joyce reformed?

[Musley]

I don't know why but I was wondering to myself yesterday that if Johnny, Andy & Mike reformed with a new front man and performed only Smiths songs, would anyone go to see them. Would you?

 

[oye terence]

I don't know why but I was wondering to myself yesterday that if Johnny, Andy & Mike reformed with a new front man and performed only Smiths songs, would anyone go to see them. Would you?

it would be like seeing journey without steve perry.
just a cold hollow shell.
okay,i will be more hip and say it would be like seeing pulp without jarvis cocker.

would i see a new group if it was them and they tried something different?
sure.

 

[modrevolve]

Funny I was wondrering the same seeing as how "From the Jam" is selling out all over without the aid of Paul Weller.

 

[oye terence]

Funny I was wondrering the same seeing as how "From the Jam" is selling out all over without the aid of Paul Weller.

ugh.

without the modfather i wouldnt wanna see that.

 

[the judge]

If Morrissey, Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce + Bernard Butler reformed, would you go to see them?

 

[oye terence]

If Morrissey, Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce + Bernard Butler reformed, would you go to see them?

hell yes!!

haha

 

[modrevolve]

ugh.

without the modfather i wouldnt wanna see that.

Apparently they hired some guy from a Jam tribute band to take his place. The idea of Marr, Rourke and Joyce with one of those Mozzerlikes from a tribute band would be utterly hilarious.

 

[modrevolve]

If Morrissey, Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce + Bernard Butler reformed, would you go to see them?

Was anything ever recorded when Bernard played with the Verve for a week?

 

[Kewpie]

Doors, Queen, Jam, Undertones, Stranglers etc have done it.

We all know Johnny is not desparete to do this kind of thing.

 

[oye terence]

Apparently they hired some guy from a Jam tribute band to take his place. The idea of Marr, Rourke and Joyce with one of those Mozzerlikes from a tribute band would be utterly hilarious.

see,that just makes me a little sad on the inside,i mean,i feel bad for them but that just screams desperation.
didnt some other band do that?find some tribute band singer to take over?

its not the jam with out weller just like its not the smiths without morrissey

 

[sweet and tender hooligan]

I seen From the Jam live and they totally blew me away of course i didn't see the Jam live but basing it on that i can see it working.

 

[the judge]

Apparently they hired some guy from a Jam tribute band to take his place. The idea of Marr, Rourke and Joyce with one of those Mozzerlikes from a tribute band would be utterly hilarious.

yessss
Like Briber's uncle!

 

[modrevolve]

see,that just makes me a little sad on the inside,i mean,i feel bad for them but that just screams desperation.
didnt some other band do that?find some tribute band singer to take over?

its not the jam with out weller just like its not the smiths without morrissey

it was Judas Priest..which was the basis for the movie Rock Star with Mark Wahlberg..I am full of useless information today.

 

[the judge]

Was anything ever recorded when Bernard played with the Verve for a week?

dunno

Doors, Queen, Jam, Undertones, Stranglers etc have done it.

We all know Johnny is not desparete to do this kind of thing.

I agree.

 

[Skinner]

it was Judas Priest..which was the basis for the movie Rock Star with Mark Wahlberg..I am full of useless information today.

That actually the state of Journey at the moment too (ok I'll be the loser to bring it up). They currently have a singer from the Philippines who was in a Journey tribute band. Its funny because he sounds just like Steve Perry but he's very Asian looking so you are expecting to see Steve Perry (white dude with a mullet), but you end up seeing something totally different haha.

 

[I am a Ghost]

It would be like Harpo, Chico and Zeppo, but no Groucho....

 

[Amy]

I don't know why but I was wondering to myself yesterday that if Johnny, Andy & Mike reformed with a new front man and performed only Smiths songs, would anyone go to see them. Would you?

Never.

 

[dicartwright]

I would lose respect for Johnny.

 

[Skinner]

I would lose respect for Johnny.

Yes that is also correct.

 

[Renia]

If that ever happened, my first question would not be if I wanted to see them, (that would come second.) but what would Morrissey do? I'm sure the flames and anger would burning brightly.

and then I'd laugh, and shake my head "no" sadly. It just wouldn't be the same.