
Originally Posted by
Gennasey
If the quote as reported is correct, then I understand why some people feel that he was dismissive of what happened in Norway, and I can certainly understand why they would feel hurt by that. I'm not feeling outraged, just sad, because I agree with Je Suis Julie that Morrissey's message is lost in the frenzied whirlpool of emotional reaction to his comment. And I can see how this would be frustrating to people who agree with his message and want to see more attention paid to animal rights issues.
Really, the only fact of this story is that, to Morrissey, a life is a life is a life is a life. And, no, that shouldn't be a surprise to his fans.
However, I see no positive effect, nothing that will further the cause of animal rights, in saying one tragedy is "nothing compared to" another. Though I agree that he was speaking statistically, I suspect that both the cow and the human, when facing the executioner, feel much the same terror and don't particularly care about numbers. And when it's the suffering you're concerned with, I don't understand making comparisons.
Just as someone mentioned earlier that people were complaining about giving sympathy to Amy Winehouse when there's this awful tragedy in Norway, people like that don't seem to understand that it is actually possible for a person to feel sorrow about MANY things at the same time. It's also possible to stand up for one cause without harming another. I passionately believe in doing all we can to prevent unnecessary suffering and cruelty in a world that seems to be saturated in it, and I think we do that when we're thoughtful in both deeds AND words.