Morrissey #57 in Paste Magazine's 100 Best Living Songwriters (Jun/Jul Issue#22)
posted by davidt on Wednesday July 19 2006, @11:00AM

mozmic_dancer writes:
In the June/July Issue of Paste Magazine (Issue #22), Morrissey is included in their 100 Best Living Songwriters feature. The list was compiled by writers and musicians. He was listed at #57.

You can view the entire list here

Also included were remarks by writer William Bowers about Morrissey:

_____________

#57 Morrissey

"Irish blood, English heart, this I'm made of / There is no one on earth I'm afraid of / And I will die with both of my hands untied"

Why bother attempting to separate Morrissey the lyricist from Morrissey the meme? Life is too nasty, brutish and short. Steven Patrick's whole super-idiom is based on reckless blendings: of Wildean wit with the melodrama of a Keats cultist; of humble, other-directed story singing with status-obsessed self-mythologizing; of James Dean/rockabilly style with blousey, glam foppery; of the timeless (Joan Of Arc) with the ephemeral (her Walkman); of soggy sensitivity toward animals and the meek with murderous aggression toward DJs and the powerful; of randy flamboyance with puritanical abstinence; of andro-pop advocacy (yay New York Dolls) with andro-pop dissuasion (boo Elton John); of sagacious subtlety with cretinous bluntness.

Prancing and athletic, his insistence on his own significance -- and his ability to pen couplets defined by universal desires -- make him appealing to the most machismo-driven Manes and Mexican-Americans, as well as the prissiest. (Unfrustrated, normative boys love him, too. Not to mention the ladies.) He's intellectual cheesecake, a reactionary libertine, a solitary populist, an effete aristocrat with the heart of a dole-bound vandal. He transcends gender differentials, and milks them for all that they're worth. He's an evergreen rake, and a bit of a dinosaur -- which is no diss: what other fossil inspires such immediate awe?

Even his physiognomy -- that famous jut jaw -- suggests invulnerable defiance and a weak spot ripe for cheap shots. Throngs of emotionally over-invested fans analyze his compositions like bankers divining a Federal Reserve Chair's prophecy, and yet a compilation disc could be filled with songs defaming him (though The Mountain Goats' John Darnielle has retracted his, and even inscribed a copy of his zine for me with, "William, it was really nothing").

Johnny Marr apologists may bemoan how much harder-to-dance to the solo career has been, as if The Smiths' legacy isn't unassailable, but the Morrissey freed up to sermonize can be just as interesting as the Morrissey shackled to impulse (which is to say that a pulpit in a salon is just as interesting as a "Vicar In A Tutu"). Homemade topical box sets could divide his songs into numerous fascinating categories -- Shaming The Prales, or Cryptically About VD -- and still only be scratching the surface of the work of this postmodern relic, who kicked off his first post-Smiths singles collection with the lines, "Off the rails I was, and / Off the rails I was happy to stay." Get out of his way!

GET: "Ask" (with Johnny Marr, 1986), ''There Is A Light That Never Goes Out" (with Johnny Marr, 1986), "Everyday is Like Sunday" (with Stephen Street, 1988).


 
Morrissey-solo Login
Nickname:

Password:

Public Terminal

[ Create a new account ]

Related Links
· here
· More News/Media stories
· More Index stories
· Also by davidt

* [ Add a comment to this item ]

Morrissey #57 in Paste Magazine's 100 Best Living Songwriters (Jun/Jul Issue#22) | Log in/Create an Account | Top | 59 comments | Search Discussion
Threshold:
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
Pathetic (Score:0)
Was this list compiled by utter morons?... i think its obvious that it was.
Anonymous -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @11:30AM (#228766)
[ Reply to this comment ]
  • Re:Pathetic by defari (Score:1) Friday July 21 2006, @08:05AM
    Pointless (Score:0, Redundant)
    No John Lennon yet McCartney is top 10, Dolly Parton beats Moz? sure. Nick Cave on the wrong end of the 100 too.

    Are all top xx lists just a pointless excercise? see C4 music of the millenium and nearly every NME list add all Uncut and Q lists too, they serve nothing and to be honest the only debate that arises is the collective acknowledgment of the poor quality of all these list.

    I also think the most influencial band of the 20th century NME bestowed upon the Smiths was silly too.
    MonaTone -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @11:38AM (#228767)
    (User #8543 Info | http://www.geocities.com/Monatonetheband/Monatonetheband.html )
    "I drink to forget, but I only remember" - Sack!
    [ Reply to this comment ]
    • Re:Pointless by mozmic_dancer (Score:1) Wednesday July 19 2006, @12:06PM
      • Re:Pointless by Vauxhall Victor (Score:1) Thursday July 20 2006, @12:12PM
      Elvis Costello (Score:1)
      above Moz AND Nick Cave AND R.E.M?

      I just don't get it.

      But then again, I've never really "got" Elvis Costello either. Or Tom Waits for that matter.
      veradicere * -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @11:42AM (#228768)
      (User #8315 Info)
      [ Reply to this comment ]
      crap list... (Score:0)
      morrissey deserves much higher...
      bob dylan number one? he's a fossil.
      and overrated to boot.
      Anonymous -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @11:59AM (#228775)
      [ Reply to this comment ]
        syd barrett is on the list... (Score:1, Interesting)
        ouch.
        chrisarclark <clarkinatorclark@hotmail.com> -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @12:09PM (#228780)
        (User #9259 Info)
        "I'm just passing through here on my way to somewhere civilized and maybe I'll even arrive, maybe I'll even arrive..."
        [ Reply to this comment ]
        this joke isnt funny (Score:0)
        there are not 56 people in history
        dead or alive better at writing sing then moz

        markmustb1
        Anonymous -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @12:13PM (#228782)
        [ Reply to this comment ]
        ask? (Score:1, Insightful)
        pale in comparison to other Smith's gems.
        sorry, but true.
        Anonymous -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @09:09PM (#228818)
        [ Reply to this comment ]
        • Re:ask? by Anonymous (Score:0) Thursday July 20 2006, @03:42AM
          List is not that bad (Score:0)
          The order is.
          At least they did not put Kurt Cobain @#1 again
          oh ooops he dont qualify.
          Anonymous -- Wednesday July 19 2006, @09:38PM (#228820)
          [ Reply to this comment ]
            laughable (Score:1)
            purely laughable.
            a real giggle compiled by rednecks.
            lots of music with country origins in there.
            and beck beating mozz, please.
            i wont bang on........

            inlovewiththepast -- Thursday July 20 2006, @12:51AM (#228830)
            (User #1028 Info)
            truth rest your head there is more than a life at stake here..she may well sell sanctuary but she'll also sell your soul
            [ Reply to this comment ]
              Do you really care? (Score:1)
              As I am not an english mother-tongue person, I might not be the right person to judge.
              However, I fond Moz lyrics so sophisticated and unique that I could not believe why he is listed so low.
              Let them do it...we, charming men, know where he should be.
              umbyyy -- Thursday July 20 2006, @04:02AM (#228850)
              (User #16573 Info)
              [ Reply to this comment ]
                Whose Top 100? (Score:1)
                That list was brilliant - I am appalled that Moz made it at all! What company to keep??? You can tell that the list was created by a person (or people) of a 'certain age' shall we say? I also take it that this is a US rag?
                Elsie -- Thursday July 20 2006, @07:27AM (#228869)
                (User #16918 Info)
                "The more scholastically educated a man is generally, the more he is an emotional bore"
                [ Reply to this comment ]
                  Re:Whose Top 100? (Score:2, Insightful)
                  You would assume right, Elsie. I've neglected to say that Paste Magazine is a US rag produced by the good people in Decatur, Georgia.

                  It's an expensive little rag at $8.95, but sometimes worth it. It's released bimonthly and includes a cd or dvd sampler in every issue. It primarily focuses on alternative, indie and Americana music. It recently included movie/rental reviews.

                  I'm not too sure about their age target. My impression from their content is that they try for an even balance featuring established artists along with the up and coming talent.

                  mozmic_dancer -- Thursday July 20 2006, @08:09AM (#228877)
                  (User #11277 Info)
                  "I am the fun and the fair, on a Mozsite for the criminally insane..."
                  [ Reply to this comment | Parent ]
                I'm just pissed... (Score:1, Funny)
                that Stephin Merritt didn't make the list, or Stuart Murdoch for that matter!
                Anonymous -- Thursday July 20 2006, @08:04AM (#228875)
                [ Reply to this comment ]
                  What a Joke (Score:1, Interesting)
                  Tom Waits at #4? How many songs by Mr. Waits can anyone name? Who has he influenced? Neil Young #2? He'd be that high on a list of worst voices in popular music, but not for songwriting prowess. In short, he sucks. Brian Wilson #7? Nice catchy surf songs from 40 years ago and 'Pet Sounds' was ahead of its time, but what about the entire body of work? How many songs has he actually written? Chuck Berry? He had a profound impact on rock and roll guitar, but he wrote 1 song in his life! He just changed around lyrics ranging from ding-a-lings to chevrolets. James Brown? Deep lyrics and a great voice...what a joke! Dolly Parton? Quick, name your five favorite albums by Sufjan Stevens, make that five favorite songs by Sufjan Stevens. Does anyone have a favorite song by Sufjan Stevens? I read that his 'Illinois' is a fave of the critics, but does one well-received album, who 100 people have heard actually catapult him above Morrissey? Look, the top 10 HAS to include Mick and Keith, Morrissey, Ray Davies, REM, Paul Westerberg, and Pete Townshend. Mix them up how you choose and add another 4, I don't care but don't tell Me Tom Waits is #4 and Neil Young is #2...I don't know where to put Bob Dylan, he used to be great a long time ago, but #1? This list has raised my blood pressure to a dangerous level. I'm going to lay down.
                  Anonymous -- Thursday July 20 2006, @08:54AM (#228882)
                  [ Reply to this comment ]
                  William, take a bow(ers) (Score:1)
                  I like what this man says. I like his style. He writes well. Not all fans of the Moz are as moronic as those who post anonymously on this site, clearly.

                  Well done, that man.
                  boredhousewife -- Thursday July 20 2006, @11:17AM (#228900)
                  (User #13144 Info)
                  [ Reply to this comment ]
                  Top 100 / Readers' Choices (Score:1)
                  For those interested in the results of the Readers' poll, you can view the list here [pastemagazine.com]
                  mozmic_dancer -- Thursday July 20 2006, @01:50PM (#228928)
                  (User #11277 Info)
                  "I am the fun and the fair, on a Mozsite for the criminally insane..."
                  [ Reply to this comment ]
                  Paste my arse (Score:1)
                  i just can't believe that Morrissey, Stephen Malkmuss or even Outkast struck on the mediocre position fool of all. the so well talented songwriter like them should be on the top 20, at least. a typical like Outkast at no 90's?! what a mag!
                  Peter Marr -- Friday July 21 2006, @01:15AM (#228964)
                  (User #17077 Info)
                  [ Reply to this comment ]
                    At least they got #1 right... (Score:0)
                    but Morrissey (and Nick Cave) should have been so much higher. Morrissey and Bob Dylan are two my favourite artists.

                    I read comment's bout Bob Dylan being a fossil or that he used to be great, but isn't anymore. Well my opinion is that his best album was released in 1997 ('Time Out of Mind') and one of his best tracks 'Cross The Green Mountain' is only few years old. Can't wait for the new album released next month.

                    And Tom Waits is on the right spot. Or perhaps he too should've been higher (#2 or #3). Someone wondered if anyone can name any of his songs. Well, I can name a hundred. He's propably written eight out of ten most touching songs ever released. Like Morrisssey he too has extremely beautiful voice, but of course in a very different way.

                    Niin ja englanti ei ole äidinkieleni, eli siitä johtuvat kaikki kirjoitusvirheet, joten niitä on turha kommentoida. Olen myös juonut pullollisen punaviiniä, mikä on myös omiaan edesauttamaan mahdollisten kirjoitusvirheiden syntyä.
                    Anonymous -- Friday July 21 2006, @02:43PM (#229026)
                    [ Reply to this comment ]


                    [ home | submit story/news item | archive/search | past polls | faq | preferences | terms of service | rss ]